2020 Yankees: Luke Voit’s Position

The New York Yankees have a new first baseman for the 2020 season, and his name is Luke Voit.

Checkout this video:

2020 Yankees: Luke Voit’s Position

Yankees first baseman Luke Voit has been on a tear lately, batting .333 with four home runs in his last 10 games. With the Yankees currently in first place in the AL East, Voit’s production at the plate has been a big reason why. But with the Yankees’ top prospect, Clint Frazier, waiting in the wings, some have been wondering if Voit’s days as the Yankees’ starting first baseman are numbered.

The Case for Voit at First Base

In 2020, the New York Yankees will have a bit of a dilemma on their hands. They have two very good first basemen in Luke Voit and Greg Bird. One of them is going to have to play DH. The other is going to have to play first base. So, who should play first base? Who should be the DH?

Here’s a case for Voit at first base and Bird as the DH.

Voit is the better hitter of the two. In 2019, he hit .263/.338/.455 with 22 home runs. Bird, on the other hand, hit just .195/.288/.421 with 11 home runs. Voit also has more power and is better at getting on base. He had a .455 slugging percentage and a .338 on-base percentage in 2019 while Bird had a . 421 slugging percentage and a .288 on-base percentage.

Voit is also the better defender of the two. He had a higher defensive WAR (1.0) than Bird (0.5) in 2019 according to FanGraphs. He also had more total chances (1,277) than Bird (1,045) and made fewer errors (six). Voit also has better range than Bird according to FanGraphs’ Defensive Runs Saved metric (-2 vs -5).

So, there’s a case to be made for Voit at first base and Bird as the DH in 2020. It’s not an easy decision, but Voit is the better hitter and defender of the two and that should be enough to give him the edge over Bird at first base.

The Case for Voit at Designated Hitter

In 2020, the New York Yankees will have a bit of a logjam at first base. With Luke Voit, Greg Bird, and Mike Ford all on the roster, somebody is going to have to DH. And given Voit’s struggles in the field, it makes sense for him to be that guy.

Here’s a look at the case for Voit DHing in 2020:

-Voit is a liability in the field. He’s not a good first baseman, and he’s not even that good of a hitter. His defense is so bad that it offsets his value as a hitter.

-The Yankees have other options at first base. Both Bird and Ford are better fielders than Voit, and they’re both left-handed hitters (which is important given that the Yankees will have a right-handed heavy lineup).

-Voit’s bat would play well at DH. He has good power and he doesn’t strike out too much. Plus, he wouldn’t have to worry about playing defense, which would allow him to focus on hitting.

So there you have it: the case for Voit being the Yankees’ designated hitter in 2020. What do you think?

The Case for Voit at Both First Base and Designated Hitter

The New York Yankees have a bit of a dilemma on their hands. They have two very good players who both play the same position, first base. Luke Voit is coming off of an All-Star season in which he hit .263/.382/.520 with 22 home runs and 54 RBI. He was also one of the best defensive first basemen in the league, according to Defensive Runs Saved (DRS).

On the other hand, they have Giancarlo Stanton, who is one of the best hitters in baseball when healthy. He hit .288/.403/.511 with 38 home runs and 100 RBI in 2019, his first full season with the Yankees. He was also decent defensively at first base, but he is much better suited for designated hitter (DH).

So, what should the Yankees do? Should they put Voit at DH and keep Stanton at first base? Or vice versa? Or should they split them up and start them both at first base and DH?

I think the Yankees should start both Voit and Stanton at first base and DH. Here’s why:

1) Both players are better when they’re in the lineup everyday.
2) The Yankees need both of their bats in the lineup. 3) It would allow Aaron Judge to play more outfield, which is where he’s most valuable. 4) It would give the Yankees more depth off the bench.

What do you think?

The Pros and Cons of Voit Playing First Base

The Yankees have a depth issue at first base. Greg Bird is hurt. And while DJ LeMahieu and Mike Ford can play the position, they are much better suited for other roles. That leaves the Yankees with one option to man first base on a daily basis: Luke Voit. Voit is certainly capable of handling the position defensively. However, there are some question marks about his ability to hit for power from the left side of the plate.

The Pros of Voit Playing First Base

There are a few pros to having Voit play first base instead of Greg Bird. One is that Voit is a better hitter than Bird. He had an OPS+ of 129 last year compared to Bird’s 97. In other words, Voit was 29% better than Bird as a hitter last year. He also hits for more power, as evidenced by his 18 home runs compared to Bird’s 11.

Another pro is that Voit is a better defender than Bird at first base. In 2018, Voit had a Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) of 2 at first base, while Bird had a DRS of -7. In other words, Voit was nine runs better than Bird as a defender at first base last year.

Finally, the Yankees have depth at the DH spot with Edwin Encarnacion and Giancarlo Stanton. This means that they can keep both Voit and Bird in the lineup and not have to worry about one of them being exposed to the DH spot.

The Cons of Voit Playing First Base

There are a few reasons why some people think Voit should not play first base for the Yankees in 2020. First, Voit is not considered to be a great defensive player. He made seven errors in 2019, and his range factor was below average. Second, Voit is coming off of an injury-plagued 2019 season, during which he played in only 122 games. And third, the Yankees have a very deep lineup, and there are other options (such as DJ LeMahieu) who could play first base and provide more offensive production.

The Pros and Cons of Voit Playing Designated Hitter

The 2020 New York Yankees have been a juggernaut offensively, and a big reason for that has been the play of Luke Voit. Voit has been one of the best hitters in baseball this season, and he has been doing it all while playing primarily designated hitter. While this has been great for the Yankees, there are some who feel that Voit should be in the field playing first base. Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of Voit playing designated hitter.

The Pros of Voit Playing Designated Hitter

Since Luke Voit joined the Yankees in 2018, he’s been one of the team’s most consistent hitters. In 2019, he hit .278/.392/.545 with 33 home runs and had an OPS+ of 140. He’s also a defensively capable first baseman, having started 62 games there in 2019.

There are a few reasons why Voit could be even more valuable to the Yankees if he played designated hitter full-time in 2020. First, it would allow manager Aaron Boone to keep Voit’s bat in the lineup on a daily basis while still getting him regular days off from first base to stay fresh. Second, it would give the Yankees more flexibility with their lineup, as they could use DJ LeMahieu at first base or third base on days when Voit is DHing. Third, it would allow Boone to use Gary Sanchez more exclusively at catcher, which would help keep him healthy and improve his defense.

There are some drawbacks to having Voit play DH full-time, however. First, it would take away one of his best attributes – his defense at first base. Second, it would limit the Yankees’ ability to use him as a pinch-hitter late in games, as they did on multiple occasions in 2019. Third, it could create a logjam at DH if Giancarlo Stanton is healthy and able to play regularly in 2020.

Ultimately, whether or not Voit should be the Yankees’ primary designated hitter in 2020 will come down to Aaron Boone and how he wants to use him. But there’s no question that Voit has the potential to be an even more valuable player for the Yankees if he spends more time DHing next season.

The Cons of Voit Playing Designated Hitter

One of the main reasons why some people are against Voit playing designated hitter is that they feel it would be a waste of his talents. Voit is considered to be a good defensive first baseman, and many feel that his defense is one of the reasons why he is so valuable to the Yankees. By moving him to designated hitter, Voit would no longer be able to contribute defensively, and some feel that this would make the Yankees weaker overall.

Another reason why people are opposed to Voit playing designated hitter is that they feel it would limit his value as a player. Voit is considered to be a good two-way player, meaning he contributes both offensively and defensively. If he were only used as a designated hitter, he would only be contributing offensively, and many feel that this would make him less valuable overall.

The final reason why some people are against Voit playing designated hitter is because they feel it could lead to injury. First basemen are often required to make diving catches and other acrobatic defensive plays. By moving Voit to designated hitter, he would no longer be exposed to these types of plays, and some feel this could lead to him getting injured less often.

The Pros and Cons of Voit Playing First Base and Designated Hitter

First Baseman Luke Voit is one of the key players on the 2020 New York Yankees. His positional versatility allows the Yankees to use him at first base or as a designated hitter. However, there are pros and cons to Voit playing both positions. Let’s take a closer look.

The Pros of Voit Playing First Base and Designated Hitter

Luke Voit is one of the key members of the 2020 New York Yankees. A powerful force in the middle of the lineup, Voit is another example of the team’s depth and potential. As Voit enters his second full season with the Yankees, there is some debate about what his best position is. Should he be the everyday first baseman? Or would he be better suited as a designated hitter?

There are pros and cons to both positions. As a first baseman, Voit would be able to contribute defensively. He has shown that he can handle the position well, and his athleticism allows him to make plays that other first basemen might not be able to make. Additionally, being in the field would keep Voit fresh throughout the game and could potentially prolong his career.

However, there are also benefits to having Voit serve as the designated hitter. For one thing, it would allow him to focus solely on hitting, which is what he does best. Additionally, it would allow for better lineup construction overall. With Voit at DH, manager Aaron Boone would have more flexibility when it comes to putting together a lineup that can score runs and put pressure on opposing pitchers.

Ultimately, whether or not Voit plays first base or DH will come down to what Boone thinks is best for the team. But regardless of where he hits in the lineup or where he plays in the field, there’s no doubt that Voit will be an important part of the Yankees’ quest for a 28th World Series title in 2020.

The Cons of Voit Playing First Base and Designated Hitter

There are a few cons to Luke Voit playing both first base and designated hitter for the New York Yankees in 2020. First, Voit is not an elite defensive first baseman. He’s serviceable, but he’s not going to win any Gold Glove awards. Second, the Yankees already have a lot of depth at first base and DH with Greg Bird and Kendrys Morales. Adding another player to the mix could create a logjam and make it difficult for Voit to get regular playing time. Finally, Voit’s bat may be better suited for DH than first base. He’s a power hitter with a career .841 OPS as a DH compared to .726 OPS as a first baseman.