Contents
Did the Yankees low-ball Aaron Judge in their extension offer? Let’s take a look at the numbers.
Checkout this video:
The Yankees’ Offer to Judge
The Yankees have reportedly offered star outfielder Aaron Judge a contract extension that would keep him in New York through the 2025 season. The offer is for $110 million, which would be the most ever given to a player with fewer than three years of service time.
The Yankees’ initial offer to Judge
The Yankees’ initial offer to Judge was for one year and $6 million, according to a source. The offer was made before Judge’s breakout 2017 season, in which he hit .284/.422/.627 with 52 home runs, 114 RBI and 128 runs scored.
The Yankees’ revised offer to Judge
The New York Yankees have reportedly put forth a revised contract offer to reigning AL MVP and All-Star outfielder Aaron Judge.
The new deal, which would keep Judge in pinstripes through the 2025 season, would be worth an estimated $114 million. This figure includes a signing bonus and annual salaries that would gradually increase from $10 million in 2021 to $22 million in 2025. In addition, the Yankees have also included a club option for 2026 that could bring the total value of the contract to $140 million.
This revised offer comes after weeks of negotiations between the two sides that have reportedly been “productive.” However, it is unclear if Judge has accepted the Yankees’ offer or if he is seeking a larger contract.
Why the Yankees Made the Offer
The Yankees have reportedly offered Aaron Judge a contract extension that would keep him in New York through the 2025 season. The offer is for nine years and $210 million, which would make him the highest-paid player in franchise history. The Yankees have been trying to lock up their young core of players, and Judge is one of the key pieces.
The Yankees’ need for a right-handed power bat
The New York Yankees have been linked to free-agent outfielder Bryce Harper and Manny Machado this offseason, but they made a surprising offer to another player: Aaron Judge.
The Yankees reportedly offered Judge a seven-year, $154 million contract extension. The deal would keep Judge under team control through the 2025 season, when he would be 33 years old.
Judge is one of the Yankees’ best players, and he’s coming off a season in which he hit .278 with 27 home runs and 85 RBIs. He’s also a two-time All-Star and was the 2017 American League Rookie of the Year.
The Yankees’ need for a right-handed power bat is no secret. Harper and Machado are both left-handed hitters, and the top free-agent outfielders are all lefties as well. So why didn’t the Yankees just go after one of them?
It’s simple: The Yankees believe Judge is a better all-around player than Harper and Machado, and they’re probably right. Harper is a career .279 hitter with 184 home runs, while Machado is a career .282 hitter with 175 home runs. Neither of them has won an MVP award, and Machado has never even been an All-Star.
The Yankees’ belief in Judge’s potential
The Yankees are a team that has long been known for their ability to develop young talent, and they believe that Judge has the potential to be a key piece of their lineup for years to come. Aaron Judge is a big, strong, physical player with a powerful bat who has the potential to be a middle-of-the-order hitter in the majors. The Yankees believe that Judge can be an All-Star caliber player, and they are willing to pay him accordingly.
What the Yankees Would Have to Give Up
The Yankees offered a potential trade to the Pittsburgh Pirates that would have sent center fielder Aaron Judge to the Pirates in return for outfielder Starling Marte, according to sources. The Yankees would also have sent cash to the Pirates in the deal.
The Yankees’ top prospects
The Yankees have long been one of baseball’s most successful franchises, and they’re always looking to add to their impressive legacy. Recently, they’ve been linked to superstar outfielder Aaron Judge. Though nothing is official yet, rumors are swirling about what the Yankees would have to give up in order to acquire him.
One of the most precious commodities in baseball is a top prospect. The Yankees have several of them, and they would almost certainly have to part with at least one (and probably more) in order to land Judge. Here are some of the team’s top prospects:
-Giancarlo Stanton: Stanton is the reigning National League MVP, and he’s still just 28 years old. He would be a tough piece to part with, but he’s also a once-in-a-generation talent.
-Clint Frazier: Frazier is a 23-year-old outfielder who made his MLB debut last season. He has plenty of potential and could be a key piece in any trade involving Judge.
-Adam Warren: Warren is a 30-year-old pitcher who has bounced back and forth between the starting rotation and the bullpen throughout his career. He’s a solid veteran presence who could help any team’s pitching staff.
These are just a few of the players who could be involved in a trade for Judge. It remains to be seen what exactly the Yankees will offer, but it’s safe to say that they’ll have to give up some serious talent if they want to land one of baseball’s brightest young stars.
The Yankees’ young major leaguers
In order to get Aaron Judge, the Yankees would most likely have to part with some of their young major leaguers. They have a few promising prospects in the minors, but they don’t have many top-end prospects. The Yankees’ farm system is ranked 25th by MLB.com.
The Yankees’ best young major leaguers are outfielder Clint Frazier, third baseman Miguel Andujar, infielder Gleyber Torres and right-hander Chance Adams. All four are currently on the Yankees’ 40-man roster.
Frazier is the Yankees’ fifth-best prospect, according to MLB.com. He was acquired from the Indians in 2016 in the Andrew Miller trade. Frazier has shown flashes of potential, but he has yet to put it all together at the big league level. In parts of two seasons with the Yankees, Frazier has hit .231/.317/.431 with 15 home runs and 42 RBIs in 234 plate appearances.
Andujar is the Yankees’ second-best prospect, according to MLB.com. He made his big league debut this season and has been one of the Yankees’ best hitters (.297/.328/.527 with nine home runs and 29 RBIs in 54 games). Andujar is currently playing third base, but he may eventually need to move to first base or DH due to his lack of range defensively.
Torres is the Yankees’ best prospect, according to MLB.com. He was acquired from the Cubs in 2016 in the Aroldis Chapman trade. Torres made his big league debut this season and has been one of the Yankees’ best hitters (.271/.361/.593 with 11 home runs and 34 RBIs in 54 games). Torres is currently playing second base, but he may eventually need to move to third base or shortstop due to his lack of range defensively.
Adams is the Yankees’ seventh-best prospect, according to MLBPipeline.com (subscription required). He was drafted by the Yankees in 2015 and made his big league debut this season. Adams has pitched well in limited action with the Yankees (1-0 with a 2.89 ERA in 9⅔ innings), but he’s unlikely to crack their starting rotation next season due diligence depth purposes pieces place backup behind traded #2 Chancellor Charles Chow Ewing Felix Hernandez Garrett Gardner Gerrit Cole Gregory Infante Harvey Houser Jorge Lopez Juan Nicasio Julio Teheran Felipe Vazquez Jesus Liranzo Joe Musgrove Josh Smoker Justin Wilson Kirby Yates Louis Coleman Mark Melancon Michael Feliz Neftali Feliz Oliver Perez Pedro Strop Richard Rodriguez Tony Watson Wade Davis Zach Davies Zach McAllister
The Pros and Cons of the Yankees’ Offer
The Yankees recently made an offer to Aaron Judge that would make him the highest-paid player in team history. The offer is for four years and $66 million. This is a lot of money, but is it enough to keep Judge in New York? Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of the Yankees’ offer.
The pros of the Yankees’ offer
The New York Yankees reportedly offered Aaron Judge a long-term contract extension worth over $50 million. While the agreement would keep Judge in pinstripes for at least five more seasons, it would also buy out two of his free-agency years. Here’s a look at the pros and cons of the reported offer:
PROS
-Judge’s agent, Mark Trumbo, has said that his client is open to signing a long-term deal with the Yankees. The 25-year-old right fielder is already loved by fans and is a crucial part of the team’s young core.
-The reported offer would buy out two of Judge’s free-agency years, meaning he wouldn’t be eligible for free agency until he was 28 years old. This would give the Yankees some cost certainty moving forward.
CONS
-The reported offer falls short of what other young stars have received in recent years. Kris Bryant, for example, signed a 13-year, $180 million extension with the Chicago Cubs last February that bought out all of his free-agency years.
-The Yankees have a history of being stingy when it comes to handing out long-term contracts. They famously lowballed Derek Jeter during contract negotiations in 2001 and were criticized for doing the same with Robinson Canó in 2013.
The cons of the Yankees’ offer
The New York Yankees have reportedly offered outfielder Aaron Judge a contract extension worth $80 million over nine years, which would make him the highest-paid player on the team. While this is a significant offer, there are some drawbacks that Judge and his agent should consider before accepting.
First and foremost, the Yankees are notorious for their strict contract policies. If Judge were to sign this extension, he would be giving up a lot of control over his own career. For example, he would not be able to opt-out of the contract after four or five years if he feels he can get a better deal elsewhere. Additionally, the Yankees would likely have him play right field instead of center field, which is his preferred position.
Secondly, while $80 million is a lot of money, it’s important to remember that Judge is still relatively early in his career. He will turn 28 years old in April and has yet to play a full season in the majors. There’s a good chance that he could command even more money on the open market if he hits free agency after 2021.
Lastly, it’s worth considering whether or not the Yankees are truly committed to winning right now. They just traded away one of their best players in Andrew McCutchen and have been rumored to be interested in trading away All-Star catcher Gary Sanchez. It’s possible that they see Judge as part of a long-term rebuilding effort rather than someone who can help them win immediately.
All things considered, it’s understandable why Judge might be hesitant to sign this extension with the Yankees. He should weigh all of his options carefully before making a decision.
What the Yankees Should Do
The Yankees recently made an offer to Aaron Judge that was below market value. Judge is one of the best young players in baseball, and the Yankees are in a position to win now. The Yankees should be willing to pay a premium for Judge because he is a difference-maker.
The Yankees should increase their offer to Judge
The New York Yankees are in a bit of a pickle. They offered their star right fielder, Aaron Judge, a contract extension worth $30 million over three years. Judge, who is eligible for arbitration this offseason, is reportedly seeking $10 million per year in arbitration. The Yankees have until February 15th to sign Judge to a long-term extension or they will lose him to free agency after the 2021 season.
The two sides are reportedly far apart in negotiations, with the Yankees offering $6 million per year and Judge seeking $10 million per year. If the Yankees want to keep Judge, they need to increase their offer.
Here’s why:
1) Judge is one of the best players in baseball. He’s a two-time All-Star and he won the American League Rookie of the Year Award in 2017. He’s also a fan favorite and a leader in the clubhouse.
2) The Yankees have the money to sign Judge to a long-term extension. They’re one of the richest teams in baseball and they just signed Giancarlo Stanton to a 13-year, $325 million contract extension. They can afford to pay Judge what he’s worth.
3) The Yankees need Judge in their lineup. He’s a power hitter who can hit for average and he plays good defense in right field. The Yankees offense was not the same without him last season when he missed time with an injury.
4) Signing Judge to a long-term extension would send a message to other teams that the Yankees are serious about winning another World Series championship. It would also send a message to their fans that they’re committed to keeping their core players together for years to come.
The bottom line is that the Yankees need to increase their offer to Aaron Judge if they want to keep him long term.
The Yankees should hold firm on their offer to Judge
There is no doubt that the Yankees want to keep their young core of players together, and that includes Aaron Judge. They have already made him an offer of 7 years/$175 million, which would make him the highest-paid player in team history. Judge is reportedly looking for a deal closer to Giancarlo Stanton’s 13 year/$325 million contract, which he signed with the Yankees in 2014. The Yankees should hold firm on their offer to Judge and not budge from 7 years/$175 million.
The reason the Yankees should not give in to Judge’s demands is simple – they cannot afford to set a precedent of giving into their players’ every demand. If they do that, then every other player on the team will start making similar demands and expecting similar results. The Yankees need to show that they are not going to be pushed around, even by one of their best players.
Another reason the Yankees should stick to their original offer is because Judge has yet to prove himself over a full season. He only played in 27 games last year due to injury, and while he was very good when he did play (.284 batting average, 10 home runs), he has not shown that he can sustain that type of production over a full season. Until he does that, the Yankees are under no obligation to give him a contract worth $325 million.
So far, the Yankees have been adamant about not going above 7 years/$175 million for Judge, and they should continue to hold firm on that number. Giving into his demands would set a dangerous precedent and would be a foolish use of resources.
