When Are the Yankees Retiring Jeter’s Number?

The Yankees have not yet announced when they will be retiring Jeter’s number, but it is likely that they will do so in the near future.

Checkout this video:

The Case for Retiring Jeter’s Number Now

The Yankees have one of the most storied histories in all of baseball, and part of that history is the retirement of iconic numbers. Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Joe DiMaggio, and Jackie Robinson all have their numbers retired by the Yankees, and many believe that Derek Jeter’s number 2 should be next. Jeter is one of the most accomplished players in Yankees history, and his number should be retired now while he is still an active player.

Jeter’s on-field accomplishments

There’s no question that Jeter was one of the best players of his generation. A five-time World Series champion, he was a 14-time All-Star and won five Gold Glove Awards. He holds numerous Yankees franchise records, including most hits (3,465), games played (2,747) and stolen bases (358). He’s also sixth on Major League Baseball’s all-time list for hits.

Jeter’s intangibles

You can make a strong statistical case that Jeter is one of the best shortstops ever to play the game. But what sets him apart are the intangibles: his competitiveness, his leadership role on teams that won five World Series, his flair for the dramatic (like his “Mr. November” home run in the 2001 World Series). All of those things are impossible to measure but make him one of the most revered athletes in New York history.

The Case for Waiting to Retire Jeter’s Number

The New York Yankees are one of the most storied franchises in all of baseball. They have won 27 World Series titles and have had some of the greatest players to ever play the game wear their uniform. One of those players is Derek Jeter, who spent his entire 20-year career with the Yankees. Jeter is widely considered to be one of the greatest Yankees of all time and is a sure-fire Hall of Famer.

Jeter’s age

Derek Jeter will turn 40 in June, and he is entering his 20th and final season with the New York Yankees. When he hangs up his cleats at the end of the season, he will have played more games and amassed more hits than any other Yankee in history.

Many fans and sportswriters are calling for Jeter’s number 2 to be retired immediately following his retirement, but there is a case to be made for waiting. Jeter is currently 14th on the all-time list for hits, and he is unlikely to move up much higher by the end of his career. If the Yankees wait a few years, there is a good chance that Jeter will be passed by players like Alex Rodriguez, Albert Pujols, and Miguel Cabrera, who are all still in their primes.

In addition, there are other players who have been with the Yankees for longer than Jeter who are deserving of consideration for retirement. Bernie Williams played 16 seasons with the Yankees and was an integral part of four World Series championship teams. He currently ranks 12th on the all-time list for hits, and he has more postseason hits than any other player in history. Paul O’Neill also played 16 seasons with the Yankees, winning five World Series titles. He ranks 20th on the all-time hits list.

Both Williams and O’Neill have been waiting over six years for their numbers to be retired, so it seems unfair to jump ahead of them just because Jeter is more popular. There is no doubt that Jeter is one of the greatest players in Yankees history, but retiring his number too soon would be a disservice to some of the other greats who have worn pinstripes.

The Yankees’ current rebuilding phase

Since the retirement of iconic Yankee shortstop Derek Jeter in 2014, the team has been in a bit of a rebuilding phase. They’ve struggled to find a consistent replacement for him at short, and haven’t made the playoffs since his final season. Some fans have been calling for the team to retire Jeter’s number 2 in honor of his legendary career, but with the team still trying to rebuild and get back to contention, is now the right time?

The case could be made that waiting to retire Jeter’s number would be a good thing for the team. By waiting until they’re back in contention and have more stability at shortstop, they can avoid any potential distraction that might come with retiring his number during a rebuilding phase. Additionally, waiting to retire his number could also make it even more special when they do eventually do it.

Ultimately, the decision of when to retire Jeter’s number 2 is up to the Yankees organization. But with the team still in a bit of flux, it might be best to wait until they’re back on solid footing before honoring one of their all-time greats.

A Compromise Solution

The New York Yankees have said they will retire Derek Jeter’s number 2 when he is eligible in 2022. However, many fans believe they should retire his number now. Let’s take a look at both sides of the argument and see if we can find a compromise solution.

Jeter’s number could be retired now, but a formal ceremony could be delayed

The New York Yankees are reportedly planning to retire Derek Jeter’s No. 2 jersey number during a special ceremony at Yankee Stadium on May 14, 2017 – scenario one.

However, some fans have suggested that the team should wait to hold the ceremony until Jeter is inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame – scenario two.

Jeter’s number is currently one of eight Yankee numbers retired, and he is widely considered to be one of the greatest baseball players of all time.

The main argument for scenario one is that Jeter deserves to have his number retired now, while he is still alive and can participate in and enjoy the ceremony. The main argument for scenario two is that Jeter’s number should not be retired until he has been inducted into the Hall of Fame, which would cement his legacy as one of the greatest players ever.

A compromise solution would be to retire Jeter’s number now, but to wait to hold the ceremony until after he has been inducted into the Hall of Fame. This would allow Jeter to enjoy the honor while he is still alive, but would also ensure that his legacy as a baseball legend is cemented for future generations.

Jeter’s number could be retired when he’s inducted into the Hall of Fame

One proposal is to wait until Jeter is inducted into the Hall of Fame, which would be five years after he retires. That way, his number can be retired when his career is celebrated in Cooperstown. This would be a good compromise solution that would appease both Jeter and the Yankees fans.


Based on the information above, it seems that the Yankees have not yet decided on a date for retirement Jeter’s number. They are waiting for him to retire first, and then they will most likely retire his number in a ceremony during the following season.

Scroll to Top