Who is the Best Player on the Yankees?

The answer to the question of who is the best player on the Yankees is difficult to determine. However, we can look at some of the metrics to get a better idea.

Checkout this video:

Why this question is difficult to answer

This is a difficult question to answer because it depends on what you are looking for in a player. Some people might say that the best player is the one who hits the most home runs, while others might say that the best player is the one who gets on base the most. There are many different ways to measure a player’s ability, so it is hard to say who the best player on the Yankees is without knowing what you are looking for specifically.

The case for Aaron Judge

In 2017, slugger Aaron Judge burst onto the scene, hitting 52 home runs and winning the AL Rookie of the Year Award. He followed that up with 27 home runs in 2018, and many people are wondering if he is the best player on the Yankees. Let’s take a look at the evidence.

His rookie season

In his rookie season, Judge set a new MLB record for most home runs by a rookie, with 52. He also led the AL in runs scored (128) and walks (127), while slugging .627 and posting an OPS+ of 155. He finished second in AL MVP voting to Jose Altuve, and was unanimously named the AL Rookie of the Year.

His performance in 2017

In 2017, Judge had a monster year, hitting 52 home runs, driving in 114 runs, and scoring 128 times. He led the majors in home runs and was second in Runs Scored. His OPS+ of 171 was the best in baseball, as was his wRC+ of 168. He was worth 7.6 fWAR, again the best in baseball. In other words, by every single measure, Judge was the best player in baseball in 2017.

The case for Giancarlo Stanton

Giancarlo Stanton is one of the best players on the Yankees. Stanton is a slugger who can hit for both power and average. He is also a great fielder and has a strong arm. Stanton is one of the most feared hitters in baseball and is a key player in the Yankees lineup.

His performance in 2017

After a slow start to the 2017 season, Giancarlo Stanton caught fire in the summer months and never looked back. He would go on to lead the Major Leagues in home runs (59) and total bases (358), while also slugging a ridiculous .631. For his efforts, Stanton was named National League MVP, edging out Joey Votto of the Cincinnati Reds.

His home run total in 2017

In 2017, Stanton shattered his previous career-high home run total, hitting 59 home runs to go along with 132 RBI. He also led the major leagues in slugging percentage (.631) and OPS (1.007), and his home run total was the second-highest in the majors behind only Aaron Judge (52).

The case for Gary Sanchez

Gary Sanchez has been one of the best players on the Yankees for the past few years. He is a great hitter and has a strong arm. He is also a good defender.

His performance in 2016

In 2016, Sanchez was one of the best players in baseball. He hit .299/.376/.657 with 30 home runs in just 53 games, and he did it while playing solid defense at catcher. He was worth 4.1 WAR in those 53 games, which prorates to about 9 WAR over a full season. That would have made him one of the 10 best players in baseball if he had played a full season.

His performance in 2017

Sanchez’s career-best season came in 2017, when he clubbed 33 homers and drove in 90 RBI in 122 games. He slashed .278/.345/.531 and posted an .876 OPS, all while playing solid defense behind the plate.

The case for Didi Gregorius

Yankees shortstop Didi Gregorius has quietly been one of the best players on the team over the last few years. He’s a great defender and has turned into a solid hitter, posting a .276/.304/.447 line in 2017. Some people may argue that other players are more deserving, but Didi is my pick for the best player on the Yankees.

His performance in 2015

Didi Gregorius had himself a breakout season in 2015. The young shortstop became one of the best players on the Yankees, hitting .265/.318/.447 with 20 home runs. He also played solid defense, making him one of the most well-rounded players on the team.

Gregorius’ numbers took a bit of a dip in 2016, but he still managed to hit .276/.304/.427 with 19 home runs. His defense also remained strong, making him one of the most valuable players on the Yankees once again.

So what makes Gregorius so special? Well, for one, he’s an excellent all-around player. He can hit for power, average, and play solid defense. He’s also a great clubhouse guy and a leader on the team.

Gregorius is still just 27 years old and has plenty of room to improve. If he can continue to develop his game, he has a chance to be one of the best players in baseball.

His performance in 2016

Let’s start with the 2016 numbers, which were outstanding. Gregorius hit .276/.304/.447 (119 wRC+) with 20 homers in 131 games. He was great defensively at shortstop, per Defensive Runs Saved and Ultimate Zone Rating. He was 2.7 wins above replacement, which made him the ninth-most valuable shortstop in baseball. His 2.7 WAR was more than double his previous career high (1.3 in 2015), and his 486 plate appearances were also a career high.


In conclusion, it is difficult to determine who the best player on the Yankees is. There are many good players on the team, and it is hard to compare them. Ultimately, it is up to the individual to decide who they think is the best player on the Yankees.

Scroll to Top