Why Do the Yankees Give Thumbs Down?

The New York Yankees are known for their “thumbs down” gesture, but why do they do it? Some say it’s because of an old tradition started by Babe Ruth. Others say it’s because the Yankees are simply the best team in baseball and they want to show it!

Checkout this video:

The Thumbs Down Tradition

The Yankees are known for giving the thumbs down when one of their players makes a mistake. The tradition started in the 1970s when Yankee players would give the thumbs down to the dugout when they made a mistake. The tradition has continued and is now a way for the Yankees to show their support for each other.

The origins of the thumbs down tradition

Thumbs down dates back to the days of Ancient Rome, when spectators at gladiator games used the gesture to indicate that they wanted a losing fighter to be spared. In more recent history, the thumbs up/thumbs down tradition is believed to have started in baseball stadiums in the early 1900s. At that time, umpires used hand signals to communicate their calls, and one of those signals was a thumb held up or down. Fans sitting in the stands began using the same gesture to voice their approval or disapproval of the ump’s calls.

The tradition is most closely associated with the New York Yankees, who are thought to be the first team to use it systematically. According to legend, Yankees manager Miller Huggins instituted a policy in 1918 that whenever an umpire made a call against his team, the players would hold up their thumbs to signal their displeasure. The fans soon picked up on this and began doing it themselves.

While the origins of the thumbs down tradition are somewhat murky, there is no doubt that it has become an integral part of Yankee lore. Whenever a player or manager makes a decision that is unpopular with the fans, they can expect to see a sea of thumbs pointed downwards in their direction.

How the tradition is carried out

The “thumbs down” tradition is carried out by the fans in the stands at Yankee Stadium during a game. When an opposing player is up to bat, the fans will hold up their thumbs and wave them back and forth to signal that they want the player to get out. The tradition is believed to have started in the early days of the stadium, when fans would actually stick their thumbs into the ground to indicate that they wanted the player to strike out.

The Significance of the Thumbs Down

The thumbs down is a sign of disapproval that has been around for centuries. In Ancient Rome, a thumbs down meant that a person was sentenced to death. In more recent history, the thumbs down has been used as a way to show disapproval of something. The most famous example of this is the scene in the movie Gladiator where the crowd gives thumbs down to the emperor. So, why do the Yankees give thumbs down?

What the thumbs down means to the Yankees

The thumbs down is a gesture that has been associated with the New York Yankees for many years. It is a sign of disapproval or dislike, and is often seen when a player makes a mistake on the field. The gesture is also sometimes seen when a Yankees player makes a bad decision off the field.

The origins of the thumbs down are unclear, but it is thought to date back to the early days of the franchise. It is possible that it started as a way for fans to show their displeasure with a player or team, but it has since become a more positive sign. Today, the thumbs down is seen as a way for Yankees fans to show their support for the team.

The thumbs down has been shown by many famous Yankees players over the years, including Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, and Yogi Berra. It is also often seen in the stands at Yankee Stadium, where it has become part of the game day experience.

What the thumbs down means to the opposing team

The Yankees aren’t the only team that has a tradition of giving the thumbs down to the opposing team, but they are certainly the most well-known. The tradition dates back to the early days of the franchise, when manager Miller Huggins would give the thumbs down signal to relief pitcher Waite Hoyt. Hoyt, who was nicknamed “The Christian Gentleman,” would then proceed to strike out the batter and seal the victory for the Yankees.

The tradition has continued throughout the years, and today it is most often seen when a Yankee player makes a great catch in foul territory. As the player makes his way back to the dugout, he will often give the thumbs down signal to indicate that he got all three outs.

While it may seem like a simple gesture, the thumbs down carries a lot of meaning for Yankee fans. It represents their team’s dominance over their opponents and is a sign of respect for their rivals. So, next time you see a Yankee player give the thumbs down, remember that it’s more than just a good luck charm – it’s a symbol of one of baseball’s most storied franchises.

The Future of the Thumbs Down

It is a tradition that dates back to the days of Babe Ruth, and it has been a part of Yankee lore ever since. Every time a player makes an out, the fans give him a thumbs down. It is a way of showing disapproval, but it is also a way of showing support. The player knows that the fans are behind him, no matter what.

Will the thumbs down tradition continue?

The New York Yankees are a baseball team with a long and successful history. One of the traditions of the team is the thumbs down gesture, which is often seen during home games. Fans will hold up their hands with their thumbs down to show their support for the team.

It is not clear where this tradition started, but it is thought to date back to the early days of the franchise. The most likely explanation is that it was started by fans who wanted to show their disapproval of the opposing team. Over time, it has become a symbol of support for the Yankees.

Despite its long history, there is no guarantee that the thumbs down tradition will continue. In recent years, there has been a decline in the number of people who do it. This could be due to a number of factors, such as the increasing age of fans, changes in the way people consume baseball, and the increasing diversity of fans.

It is possible that the Yankee organization could decide to stop encouraging the thumbs down gesture. However, it is also possible that it could become more popular than ever before. Only time will tell what the future holds for this unique tradition.

What could replace the thumbs down tradition?

The thumbs down tradition in baseball dates back to at least the early 1900s, when players and fans would use the gesture to signal their disapproval of a call by an umpire. The Yankees have made the thumbs down gesture their own, and it has become a staple of the team’s culture.

With the recent retirement of longtime Yankee captain Derek Jeter, there has been speculation that the team may retire the tradition along with him. Jeter was known for his positive attitude and leadership, and retiring the thumbs down gesture would be a way for the team to embrace a new era.

It’s unclear what, if anything, could replace the thumbs down gesture as a symbol of Yankee culture. The team has been through many changes in recent years, and it remains to be seen what traditions will continue and which will be left behind.

Scroll to Top